Phoenix urban garden mysteriously closes amid land dispute

This Tuesday, Feb. 7, 2017 photo shows some of the dozens of individual gardens at a 15-acre public gardens, in Phoenix. The sprawling urban garden on a vacant lot where central Phoenix residents have grown everything from melons to okra for years has been closed as the federal government takes over the land. (AP Photo/Ross D. Franklin)

PHOENIX (AP) — A sprawling urban garden on a vacant lot where Phoenix residents have grown everything from melons to okra closed Friday after the gardeners were mysteriously ordered out as a federal agency reassumes ownership of the land, stupefying and angering gardeners who called their eviction a classic case of government dysfunction.

Families, senior citizens and refugees spent the last week harvesting their final crops and expressing frustration that the U.S. Department of the Interior won’t say why they have to leave — or what it plans for the 15 acres of land in the shadow of high-rise apartment buildings.

The department is getting the land back from a Florida-based developer that bought it decades ago but stopped making payments promised to two Native American education trusts. The developer now owes about $60 million and is immersed in several related lawsuits, including one being settled now that gives the lot back to the government.

Caught in the middle are the gardeners, who turned the ugly lot into a tidy, verdant grow-your-own food area in Phoenix’ center.

“That lot was a fenced-in, locked-up vacant eye sore on the busiest intersection in the city of Phoenix for 20 years. We beautified it and now it’s gonna go back to being dust and Bermuda grass,” said Tom Waldeck, the chief executive of the nonprofit Keep Phoenix Beautiful group.

The garden was born from a city effort to get rid of eyesore vacant lots that emerged throughout Phoenix following the 2008 financial crisis that hit the city’s then-hot real estate boom extremely hard.

The lot’s owner, Florida-based Barron Collier Companies, had obtained the land from the federal government and agreed to allow the gardeners in.

But Barron Collier notified Phoenix officials and Keep Phoenix Beautiful late last year that the land would go back to the government and all gardeners had to vacate the premises because the government wanted the land back vacant. Interior Department spokeswoman Nedra Darling declined comment because the agency is involved in an ongoing lawsuit with Barron Collier.

Longtime U.S. Sen. John McCain, an Arizona Republican, did not get a response after he wrote a letter late last month asking about the garden’s future prospects to Acting Interior Department Secretary Kevin Haugrud. Haugrud is running the department pending a Senate confirmation vote on President Donald Trump’s interior secretary pick, Sen. Ryan Zinke, a Montana Republican.

“Complying with the request to vacate the property presents a challenge to the city of Phoenix, Keep Phoenix Beautiful and their community partners, many of whom are nonprofits who are actively engaged in community projects on site,” McCain wrote.

Phoenix’s balmy climate lets the 150 or so gardeners grow their fruit and vegetables in small plots all year. The city’s mild winter is best for broccoli, cauliflower, herbs and tomatoes while the scorching summer is good for cucumbers and melons.

Refugees resettled in Phoenix by the International Rescue Committee often grew food from their countries that they can’t find in local supermarkets. Among them was Tareke Tekie, an Eritrean refugee, who said through an interpreter that he cultivated okra and a leaf he can’t buy anywhere in the U.S.

Joanne Beard started growing broccoli and kale as a form of physical and mental therapy after she suffered a heart attack in 2013, and is angry that the empty space she helped make useful is going away.

“It’s helped me heal my body and my mind. I call it my therapy,” Beard said. “You know, this used to be just a trashed corner. It used to be so ugly, and we just made it so beautiful.”

The lot was home many years ago to the Phoenix Indian School for Native American children operated by the U.S. Bureau of Indian Affairs.

The federal government in 1988 agreed to trade it to Barron Collier for about 100,000 acres of Florida Everglades swampland that officials wanted to preserve in a deal considered the largest land trade in U.S. history.

The Florida land was valued lower than the Phoenix land, so Barron Collier agreed to pay $34.9 million plus interest to two Native American education trust accounts.

Payments started in 1997 but Barron Collier stopped making them in 2012, blaming a drop in the land’s value, according to a letter from the company to the Department of Interior dated Jan. 7, 2013. The company declined to comment.

The land is probably worth at least $32 million now and would be a good site for apartment complexes in strong demand by young professionals seeking an urban lifestyle, said Don Arones, a managing director in the Phoenix office of the Cushman & Wakefield real estate agency.

Keep Phoenix Beautiful is exploring the possibility of a nearby half-acre lot to relocate some gardeners, but there wouldn’t be enough room for all of them. Four and a half acres alone in the larger lot were being used by the refugees, Waldeck said.

The sense of community the gardeners developed as they tended their crops alongside neighbors they had never met previously is gone for the foreseeable future, Waldeck said.

“These are people who lived next door to each other and never, ever knew they existed,” he said. “We’ve had weddings, cookouts, Christmas parties here. The community aspect is really the hardest thing to take.”


Copyright 2017 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.